Thinking about getting a PhD? Disciplined Minds by Jeff Schmidt is the book to read. Already getting a PhD, ditto. Already have a PhD? You should also read this book, even though it was published way back in 2000, and relies on data from the 1980s and 1990s. It applies to today as well—little has changed. What is more, it gives an insight not only to how graduate schools seeks to shape and discipline a conservative cadre of future professors, the principles can also be applied to the pursuit of tenure for people who have made it that far.…
Author: Tony Waters
What would George Carlin Say? Might Translation be Reverse Plagiarism?
Still they ask you in court to “use your own words,” and more to the point of my profession, we tell our students to “use your own words,” and we even have fancy computer programs like “turnitin.com” that help us haul offenders off for plagiarism, which is the crime of using someone else’s own words which is, like I said above, is just about all I ever do.
The only people I can think of who made up any number of their own words are Charles Dickens, James Joyce, and Mark Twain.…
Audience Reception of “Sing Along” Music: Hey Jude 1969 vs. Michael Row the Boat Ashore 1963
I have used this clip of Pete Seeger singing “Michael Rowed the Boat Ashore” in class for some years, now. The song is a great example of how the music of the American slave cabins moved into the mainstream American culture, and then moved all the way to Australia where this clip was made in 1962 or so.
It also, I think illustrates two things about the audience, first that audiences in 1962 were very open to a “sing-a-long,” The audience knew the words, and sang along with Seeger quite competently, and in their own ways enthusiastically.…
The US Army’s Human Terrain System Bites the Dust
The Human Terrain System (HTS) was an important subject at Ethnography.com when the military began funding it in 2006-2007 or so. The program was established to bring anthropological understandings of culture into the US military in Afghanistan and Iraq.
There was a great deal of controversy in the AAA, and those of us at Ethnography.com at the time responded about the strengths and weaknesses of the program, as well as whether AAA’s approach.…
Why is Queen Nefertiti’s Bust in Berlin, and not Egypt?
Last weekend, I visited The Egyptian Queen Nefertiti this weekend on a trip to Berlin’s Neues Museum. “New” being a museum built in the mid-nineteenth century, bombed during World War II, and finally re-opened in 2009 after reconstruction following German Reunification.
The bust of Nefertiti is the Neues Museum’s best-known artifact. The Nefertiti statue is of Egypt’s Queen during the period of approximately 1370 BC-1330 BC. The statue is known for the skill that the sculptor Thutmose put into it, the well-preserved coloration, and the beauty of Nefertiti herself.…
Are Long-term Job Prospects Better for Philosophers than for Engineers?
Why philsopher’s might be optimistic about future job prospects, form Matt Buriesci at Guernia.com, in the ironically titled article “The Arts and Humanities aren’t Worth a Dime.”
Yes, really, Buriesci is predicting that future job prospects for philosophers are more promising than for engineers. Engineers can be replaced with algorithms, but sound judgment, appreciation of history, and appreciation of art is not.
Warning: This is not a quick obvious read. …
Sociologist George Carlin Expounds on the Need for Stuff!
We like our stuff. Stuff in fact is what makes the world’s capitalist markets go round. There are some well-thought out ways of describing the nature of stuff, including Karl Marx’s description of how and why “fetish commodity” is necessary to keep us consuming and buying. Then there was Torstein Veblen’s Theory of the Leisure Class. But these are both boring reads—except for geeks like me who like classical social theory.…
The Ethics of Ethnography, and Alice Goffman’s Ethnography about Crime in Philadelphia
Leon Neyfakh at Slate has written a review of the controversy surrounding Alice Goffman’s new ethnography On The Run: Fugitive Life in an American City which is about the African’ American community of inner city Philadelphia, and their relationship with the police. The essay is called “The Ethics of Ethnograpy,” and discusses the role of Institutional Research Boards, the responsibility of social scientists for replicability, the nature of scientific generalization, and the nature of ethnography. …
Multi-kulti in a German Beach Resort
We brought my mother-in-law to the Baltic Sea resort town of Ahlbeck which is near the Polish border for her 90th birthday. My mother-in-law visited the resort in one of its former heydays of the 1930s. At the time she was ten years old, and very active as a swimmer—as 90 year olds will, they wanted to visit the memories of their childhood.
Ahlbeck is on the island of Usedom, which is mostly in Germany, though a tip of the eastern part is in Poland. …
New Mandarins, Old Meritocracy, It’s All the Same Thing, Really. Commentary from 2013-2048
The Daily Beast in 2013 published a piece about “the New Mandarins” by Megan McArdle. The New Mandarins are those people who test well, get good jobs, write the tests tor the next generation, and then give birth to the next generation that will do well, and so on. The problem of course is that as in Ancient China, the Mandarins become more and more remote from the people who they rule, and the connection between the ruled and rulers becomes more tenuous. …
Mathematicians Like Social Sciences, Too!
Robert Harrington of the American Mathematical Society is trying t understand how young mathematician use their scholarly products. As an an “experiment” he tried out qualitative interview methods to investigate his question. Here is what he found out:
…As a scientist, I have ideas about what scientific method is, and what evidence is. I now understand the value of the qualitative approach – hard for a scientist to say. Qualitative research opens a window to descriptive data and analysis.
Good News on the Open Access Front
Cultural Anthropology looks like they are making a good go of Open Access. It is expanding the breadth and depth of their readership too–which makes cultural anthropology more accessible t the general public. Read their editorial here.

Tony Waters is czar and editor of Ethnography.com. He came to us from the Sociology department at California State University at Chico where he has been a professor since 1996.